incident.io Alternative: Self-Hosted On-Call Without Per-User Fees
incident.io is a polished, Slack-native incident response product that charges per user, with on-call as an add-on. OnCallAlert is a self-hosted on-call and alerting server with a flat yearly license. This page compares them honestly, including when incident.io is the better choice.
Which one should a small team pick?
Pick incident.io if your incident process lives in Slack and you want post-mortems, a catalog and a hosted service with nothing to run. Pick OnCallAlert if you mainly need reliable paging and on-call schedules at a predictable price, with alert data in your own database.
- incident.io: hosted, per user per month, incident response plus on-call and status pages.
- OnCallAlert: self-hosted, flat yearly license ($699 to $9,999), unlimited free Viewers, mobile app on Team and up.
How do the tools compare side by side?
Seven tools cover most of what small teams evaluate. Prices below are public list prices checked in November 2026; details are in the pricing table that follows. Hosting is the clearest dividing line: only OnCallAlert and GoAlert run on your own server.
| Tool | Hosting | Pricing model | Focus |
|---|---|---|---|
| OnCallAlert | Self-hosted | Flat yearly license | On-call, escalation, alert delivery, mobile app, status page |
| incident.io | Hosted | Per user, on-call add-on | Slack/Teams incident response, on-call, status pages, post-mortems |
| PagerDuty | Hosted | Per user; platform plans | On-call and incident management, broad integrations |
| Grafana IRM | Hosted (Grafana Cloud) | Per active user | On-call and incident response inside Grafana |
| Better Stack | Hosted | Per responder license | Uptime monitoring, logs, on-call, status pages |
| Rootly | Hosted | Per user, separate products | Slack-native incident response and on-call |
| FireHydrant | Hosted | Per responder; alerts metered | Incident response, runbooks, on-call (Signals) |
| GoAlert | Self-hosted | Free, Apache-2.0 | On-call scheduling and escalations only |
What does each tool cost per user per month?
incident.io Team with on-call is $25 per user per month billed annually, or $29 billed monthly. Other hosted tools list $20 to $34 per user. OnCallAlert has no per-user price: you pay a flat license and your own server. All figures were checked on the vendors' public pages in November 2026.
| Tool and plan | Annual billing | Monthly billing | Free tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| incident.io Team + on-call | $15 + $10 = $25 | $19 + $10 = $29 | Basic: free, single-team on-call |
| incident.io Pro + on-call | $25 + $20 = $45 (cycle not stated) | Not stated | n/a |
| incident.io on-call only | $20 (cycle not stated) | Not stated | n/a |
| PagerDuty Professional | $21 | $25 | Free for up to 5 users |
| Grafana IRM Pro | From $20 per active user (plus $19/month platform fee) | Not stated | Free: 3 active users |
| Better Stack responder license | $29 | $34 | Free plan for personal projects, no on-call listed |
| Rootly | Incident Response $20 + On-Call $20 = $40 (cycle not stated) | Not stated | Trial only; startup discounts |
| FireHydrant Pro | $25 per responder | Not stated | Free: up to 10 responders, no on-call listed |
| GoAlert | $0 | $0 | Free (you run it) |
| OnCallAlert | $699, $1,499, $4,999 or $9,999 per year | Team $149 and Business $499 per month | Viewers are free and unlimited |
Checked 2026-11. Enterprise plans at every vendor are "contact sales". Grafana does not define "active user" on the page we checked, and FireHydrant meters alerts and SMS or voice without listing a rate.
What does a 10, 20 or 50 user team pay in a year?
For on-call users only, incident.io Team with on-call costs $3,000, $6,000 and $15,000 a year at 10, 20 and 50 users on annual billing. OnCallAlert costs $1,499 for any of those with the mobile app, before your own server and SMS costs.
| Users on call | incident.io Team + on-call (annual) | incident.io (monthly billing) | incident.io Pro + on-call | PagerDuty Professional (annual) | OnCallAlert license |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | $3,000 | $3,480 | $5,400 | $2,520 | $1,499 (Team); $699 (Core, no mobile app) |
| 20 | $6,000 | $6,960 | $10,800 | $5,040 | $1,499 (Team) |
| 50 | $15,000 | $17,400 | $27,000 | $12,600 | $1,499 (Team, up to 50) |
Per-user figures are list price times users times 12. They assume every on-call user pays the list price, and incident.io's incident response features are part of that price, so this is a cost comparison, not a like-for-like feature comparison. The OnCallAlert column is the license only: add your own server, PostgreSQL database and any SMS or voice provider (see our pricing page), plus the time you spend on upgrades. Put your own numbers in the cost calculator.
Why does OnCallAlert cost less to own than a per-user plan?
One flat license covers your whole team: $1,499 a year (Team) for up to 50 on-call users, with unlimited free viewers. The server is a single small container, it uses the PostgreSQL you probably already run, and SMS and voice go through your own Twilio account at carrier cost.
How much does the flat license save?
The price does not change as you add responders. Team works out at about $12.49 per user a month for 10 users, $6.25 for 20 and $2.50 for 50, so the bill stays predictable while per-user plans keep climbing. Team costs less than each plan below from the number of paid users in the last column.
| Compared with | List price | Team ($1,499 a year) costs less from |
|---|---|---|
| incident.io Team plus on-call | $25 per user a month, annual | 5 users |
| incident.io Pro plus on-call | $45 per user a month | 3 users |
| PagerDuty Professional | $21 per user a month, annual | 6 users |
| Better Stack | $29 per responder a month, yearly | 5 users |
| FireHydrant Pro | $25 per responder a month, annual | 5 users |
These figures count license fees at the list prices on our Sources list (checked November 2026) and ignore taxes and add-ons. Very small teams can start on a free plan elsewhere, such as PagerDuty Free for up to 5 users, and move to OnCallAlert as the rotation grows. The Core plan ($699 a year, up to 15 users) suits teams that alert by SMS and voice, and the mobile app comes with Team and above. Past 50 users, extra 10-user packs cost $300 each on yearly plans.
What does it cost to run?
OnCallAlert is one container plus PostgreSQL 16 or newer. In our deployments the server uses roughly half a vCPU and PostgreSQL about the same at typical on-call load, and most teams already have a PostgreSQL instance, so the database often adds no new machine. We have not published a benchmark, so size it for your own alert volume. You control upgrades, backups and placement: run it on infrastructure separate from the systems it watches.
How do you keep SMS and voice bills low?
You use your own Twilio account and pay Twilio directly, with no markup from us. In the US an SMS costs roughly $0.013 per segment with carrier fees and voice about $0.014 a minute, plus a monthly number fee (list prices, so check Twilio). Hosted tools meter SMS and voice too, so this cost exists everywhere; here you see it on your own bill. See our full-screen call versus direct call breakdown for the arithmetic.
The hybrid approach is what cuts it. When the responder's phone is online, the alert arrives as a push notification from the mobile app and rings through Do Not Disturb, so no call or SMS is sent. SMS and voice fire only as a fallback when the phone is offline or the alert is not acknowledged. Every page delivered by push is a call and two SMS segments you do not pay for, about $0.04 at the list prices above, and the saving grows with alert volume. Read how mobile push replaces most SMS and voice for details. Ring-through-Do-Not-Disturb works on Android today; Apple's Critical Alerts approval for iPhone is still pending.
What does incident.io do better than OnCallAlert?
incident.io is stronger on incident process: it runs response inside Slack or Microsoft Teams, supports post-mortems and workflows, and is a hosted service you do not operate. OnCallAlert focuses on paging, schedules and escalations. If process around the incident matters more than the page, incident.io fits better.
- Slack-native and Teams-native incident response, with automation workflows.
- Post-incident process and post-mortems (Pro plan), and insights dashboards.
- Nothing to host, patch or back up; a polished product with a 99.99% uptime SLA on Enterprise.
- A free Basic plan with single-team on-call for very small teams.
Why do some teams choose OnCallAlert instead?
Teams choose OnCallAlert for a price that does not grow with headcount and for alert data that stays in their own PostgreSQL database. Only a small, documented set of calls leaves your server, listed in our how it works whitepaper.
- One flat yearly license, unlimited free Viewers for managers and stakeholders, and one public status page in every plan.
- Schedules, rotations, escalation policies and overrides, built on the open-source GoAlert project, plus a companion mobile app (Team and up).
- Terraform, OpenTofu and Pulumi provider, and an importer from PagerDuty, Opsgenie and Jira Service Management. See the docs.
When should you not switch from incident.io?
Stay on incident.io if you do not want to run a server, if your team is small enough for the free Basic plan, or if Slack-native workflows and post-mortems are the reason you bought it. Self-hosting trades a seat bill for operations work.
- You have nobody to run a Docker container and PostgreSQL, or no place to run it that your monitoring does not depend on.
- You rely on incident.io workflows, catalog or post-mortem features. OnCallAlert does not replace them.
- Your team is only a few people. At that size per-user pricing, or incident.io's free plan, can be cheaper than a flat license.
- You need many ready-made integrations. OnCallAlert accepts a generic JSON API, Grafana, Prometheus Alertmanager, Site24x7 and email; other tools may need an adapter.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a free incident.io plan?
Yes. incident.io lists a free Basic plan with Slack or Microsoft Teams incident response, single-team on-call and a status page. Multi-team on-call and alerting need the paid Team plan plus the on-call add-on (checked 2026-11).
How much does incident.io on-call cost per user?
incident.io lists Team at $15 per user per month billed annually ($19 monthly) with on-call as a $10 per user add-on, so $25 annual or $29 monthly. Pro is $25 plus a $20 on-call add-on. On-call alone is $20 (checked 2026-11).
Can I self-host incident.io?
The pages we checked describe incident.io as a hosted service, and we found no self-hosted option listed. If alert data must stay on a server you control, ask incident.io directly about data residency and enterprise options.
Does OnCallAlert replace incident.io?
Only partly. OnCallAlert covers on-call schedules, escalations, alert delivery, a mobile app and a status page. It does not offer incident.io's Slack-native incident workflows, post-mortem tooling or service catalog. Some teams run it for paging and keep a separate tool for incident process.
See what your team would pay. Compare the flat plans, or try the calculator with your headcount.
Sources (checked 2026-11)
- incident.io pricing
- PagerDuty incident management pricing
- Grafana Cloud pricing (IRM)
- Better Stack pricing
- Rootly pricing
- FireHydrant pricing
- GoAlert on GitHub (Apache-2.0)
- OnCallAlert prices from our pricing page. Vendor prices change, so confirm on the vendor's page before you decide.