A Self-Hosted PagerDuty Alternative: OnCallAlert vs. PagerDuty
PagerDuty is a mature hosted service that charges per user. OnCallAlert is on-call alerting you run on your own server, with a flat yearly license. This page compares the two, including where PagerDuty is the better fit.
The short version
- Choose OnCallAlert if you want a predictable yearly price that does not grow with headcount, want alert data in your own database, and are comfortable running a Docker container and PostgreSQL.
- Choose PagerDuty if you want a fully hosted service with nothing to run, or you depend on its large catalog of ready-made integrations and add-on products.
Side by side
| OnCallAlert | PagerDuty | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Flat yearly license per plan: $699 (up to 15 users), $1,499 (up to 50), $4,999 (up to 200), $9,999 (unlimited) | Per user, per month. List price about $21 (Professional) or $41 (Business) on annual billing |
| Where it runs | Your server: Docker image plus PostgreSQL | PagerDuty's cloud |
| Where alert data lives | Your own database | PagerDuty's cloud |
| Maintenance | You run upgrades and backups | PagerDuty runs it |
| Mobile push | Companion mobile app. Push goes through a relay we host (Team, Business and Unlimited plans) | Included mobile app |
| Alert ingestion | Generic JSON API, plus Grafana, Prometheus Alertmanager, Site24x7 and email. Other tools' alert formats are not accepted as-is | Large catalog of native integrations |
| Infrastructure as code | Terraform, OpenTofu and Pulumi provider | Terraform provider available |
| Moving over | Built-in import from PagerDuty, Opsgenie and Jira Service Management | n/a |
Comparing more than two tools? See PagerDuty alternatives compared on price and features.
What it costs, with numbers
Per-seat cost grows with every person who joins the rotation. At the list prices above, billed annually, and with an example of your own running costs added (a $15 a month server and database, and $5 a month for an SMS and voice fallback), for OnCallAlert with the mobile app:
| Team size | PagerDuty Professional | PagerDuty Business | OnCallAlert licence | OnCallAlert all-in (example) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 users | $2,520 / year | $4,920 / year | $1,499 (Team) | about $1,739 / year |
| 50 users | $12,600 / year | $24,600 / year | $1,499 (Team) | about $1,739 / year |
| 100 users | $25,200 / year | $49,200 / year | $4,999 (Business) | about $5,239 / year |
The all-in column uses made-up running costs, so replace them with your own in the cost calculator. PagerDuty add-ons are not included, and neither is the time you spend on upgrades.
The $699 Core plan (up to 15 users) does not include the mobile app relay, so every alert goes by SMS or voice. With a larger messaging bill (say $13 a month), Core comes to about $1,035 a year all-in. At these example costs, Core is cheaper than PagerDuty Professional from about 5 users, and Team (with the mobile app) from about 7 users. For a very small team (say 3 users), PagerDuty's list price ($756 a year) is lower.
What you give up
- You run the service. If your server is down, so is your alerting. Run it somewhere your monitoring does not depend on. The app itself is light: on our own beta server (database separate, light traffic) the container used about 41–46 MiB of memory and 1–2% of one CPU core while idle in November 2026. Your load will differ.
- You bring your own SMS and voice provider (for example Twilio) for the fallback. The mobile app push (Team and up) keeps that bill small.
- Fewer ready-made integrations. Tools that cannot post JSON to our alert API need a small adapter.
- No broad add-on suite around it. OnCallAlert does on-call, escalation and alert delivery.
What you get
- A price that does not change when you add the tenth, fiftieth or hundredth responder.
- Alert content stays in your database. See the privacy policy for exactly what the push relay carries. The how it works whitepaper lists every call the server makes to us.
- Schedules, rotations, escalation policies and overrides, built on the open-source GoAlert project.
- Ask AI, included in every plan: an AI triage summary on each new alert, using your own LLM provider key (bring your own key). Alert text goes from your server to your provider, not through us.
- A way in: the importer reads your PagerDuty setup and shows a preview before it changes anything. See the migration guide.
See what your team would pay. Put your own numbers into the calculator, then compare the plans.
Sources and notes
- PagerDuty list prices as reported by several pricing breakdowns in November 2026. Prices change, so check the PagerDuty pricing page before you decide.
- OnCallAlert prices from our pricing page.